About MCA

Ensuring a profitable future for Mutual Insurance Companies

Insights. Industry expertise.
Practical solutions. Transformative results.

Mutual Capital Analytics works with leaders of Mutual Insurance Companies to create products and services that help them compete more effectively in a highly regulated, increasingly competitive environment. We build, implement and optimize analytics-based solutions to drive improvements so our customers can thrive in their markets.

We help clients succeed in a rapidly changing world

Our clients recognize their world has changed. In the face of rapidly evolving technology and rising competition, Mutual Insurance Companies must transform in order to remain competitive. The time is now to capitalize on new opportunities. Yet the complexity of the tasks required are overwhelming.

To help our clients leverage a new breed of innovative capabilities, we use our expertise and experience to apply data and analytics to key business initiatives to ensure their companies can thrive for many years to come.

We help our partners manage portfolios of risk by leveraging all aspects of the insurance value chain—across distribution, underwriting, and product—so they can generate an actual return on their investment in analytics.

The MCA Story

In 2019 we saw the insurance industry had changed and mutual insurance companies were not keeping up. National insurance companies were investing heavily in data and analytics—bringing massive resources and a new generation of analytical tools—to compete in a market that hadn’t previously changed much in years.

To help Mutual insurance companies succeed in an increasingly competitive market we launched Mutual Capital Analytics. We started from the ground up, bringing years of experience leading national insurance companies. Today the team at MCA works shoulder-to-shoulder with our clients to be a long-term, strategic partner.

Unlike consultants who offer solutions without actual implementation, we roll up our sleeves and deploy the solutions we design. Once we stand up a solution, we continue to work with our customers to monitor and optimize the results. The diversity of our team’s expertise allows us to bring creative solutions across both Personal and Commercial lines.

Our Vision

Our goal is to transform the way our customers do business. We turn insights from data and analytics into an action plan that can help them compete more effectively. With every partnership we create, we use data-driven analysis, coupled with years of insurance industry experience, to help Mutual Insurance Companies discover new business opportunities, grow their companies, and improve performance.

Our Mission

Deliver custom-built data and analytics solutions that provide a high return on investment, so our Mutual insurance customers can thrive in an increasingly competitive environment.

Mutual Capital Analytics Advisory Council

As Mutual Capital Analytics continues to grow and develop as a company, we are incredibly grateful to have the insight, knowledge, and advice of our Advisory Council members. Chosen for their broad business perspectives as well as deep experience in the Mutual industry, our Advisory Council provides strategic guidance that informs our decisions as we identify and tackle the short and long-term challenges and opportunities that we have as a company.

Kate Abrey, Principal at Deloitte
Kara Raiguel, President & CEO at Gen Re
David Gautsche, CEO at Goodville Mutual Insurance Group
Ray Sprague, Managing Principal at Napatree Advisors
Bob Nicolay, Member of Board of Directors
Dave Grove, Vice President at Ohio Mutual Insurance Group
Michael Byam, Vice President at Travelers
Jeff Hay, Chief Underwriting Officer at Donegal Insurance Group